Impossible Cheeseburger Pie Recipe

Impossible Cheeseburger Pie is one of the most mouthwatering and irresistible savory pies that you’ll ever try.

With its beefy, cheesy flavor, it seriously tastes just like a cheeseburger! My boyfriend Matty ate nearly a whole pie by himself, he loved it so much.

When I finally got my fork in for a bite, I understood his delight completely.

This easy meat pie recipe delivers major comfort food satisfaction.

You likely have all the simple ingredients on hand already – ground beef, onion, cheddar cheese, eggs, Bisquick, milk, and onion soup mix. Even novice cooks can whip up this pie in under an hour.

It’s practically impossible to mess up. Take it from Matty, who declares it’s “the BEST savory pie ever!”

Should I Use Lean or Fattier Ground Beef?

Both lean and fattier ground beef would work well, lending lots of meaty flavor! I prefer lean beef because there’s already plenty of satisfying flavor from the cheese, eggs, onion soup mix, etc. With 80% lean beef, you’ll still get nice browning on the meat.

Draining excess grease also prevents the pie from getting overly oily.

But if you love the mouthfeel of fattier burgers, 85% or even 70% lean beef would make this pie extra decadent!

Should I Use Shredded or Sliced Cheese?

Good news – both shredded and sliced cheddar cheese work wonderfully! Shredded melts into the pie a bit easier.

Meanwhile, slices maintain more distinct gooey, stringy texture.

So just depends if you want creamy melted or stringy cheese texture.

For optimal flavor, use good quality real cheddar, not processed cheese product.